Ever since Edouard-Leon Scott de Martinville first miraculously captured a French lady singing a traditional folk song in 1860 (I preferred her earlier stuff) on his phonautogram, recorded music has been out there prompting debate, discussion and disagreement. And I can confirm that 149 years down the line, nothingâs changed.
Weâve always had music in the WMW office (never the radio, thoughâŠcan you really classify Fearne Cotton uniformly vomiting âbrilliiiiaannntâ and âamaaaaaazingâ to anything that dribbles out your speakers as âmusicâ?) and how we consume it has roughly mirrored the wider world: weâve gone from CDs to iPods and, now, weâre using Spotify. Or at least weâre trying to.
At first, the thought of having the worldâs biggest jukebox at our fingertips was a mouth watering prospect. Every musical whim could now be pandered toâŠwe would never have to hear a collective groan of recognition as our meagre selection of CDs and iPods was again shown up. If only it had been that easyâŠ
As our digital team hooked Spotify up, the first problem reared its head: who should have access? If everyone could put on whatever they wanted, whenever they wanted to, surely there would be some kind of meltdown in the space-time-music continuum. Did we have to fall back on good, old musical fascism: whoâs got âgoodâ taste and who likes Abba? In the end, we decided that a chosen few would have direct access with requests welcomed from the rest of the office.
And to start with, all went well. The novelty of being able to send an email requesting âLust for Lifeâ and then hearing it broadcast across the office minutes later was invigorating. But, like all novelties, it wore thin. The emails dried up (apparently something to do with having ârealâ work to do) and with their decline came a new form of responsibility. The chosen ones now had sole control of the soundtrack to everyoneâs working day. Theyâd essentially become full-time DJs.
Now fast-forward a few months down the line. The only in-house emails we receive about the music being played are complaints. Hereâs one that went around the office last week:
Who is responsible for this shouting screaming lady??
Bit harsh on Mika, but there you go. So, where did it all go wrong? With the chosen ones no longer being supported by the masses, they played what they liked. Consequently, the music became increasingly skewed to the indulgence of personal taste. Which is fine when youâve got twenty or thirty people choosing the tunes. But when itâs just a few, the music becomes more and more esoteric. You only need to look at our playlist to see it happening (in fact, you can see it live here). Whatâs worseâŠit never ends.
Unlike before when an album would come to a natural conclusion prompting someone else to put on a new one, Spotify just plays and plays. Even if your playlist finishes, it will find something else from its infinite archive. So, left unattended, potentially anything can be played. And when heads are buried deep in work, this can go unnoticed until everyone in the office starts unwittingly flapping in sync to âThe Birdie Songâ.
Now Iâm not saying some of these problems didnât exist before; one manâs TUUUUNE! is another manâs (pinches nose with fingers). But, by spoiling us with its riches, Spotify has certainly exacerbated them: we can play anything we want, so what we play should be perfect. Gone are the days of someone putting on the first office-friendly thing to hand only to be greeted with one giant shrug from the whole team.
The unrest got so bad that last week our digital guy did the 21st century equivalent of picking up his ball and going homeâŠhe unplugged his cables and took them home.
Heâs since calmed down and brought them back, but who know how things will turn out? Maybe weâll give more people access to Spotify in a bid to restore the status quo. Maybe weâll instigate an albums-only policy to create more cohesiveness. Maybe weâll conclude that Spotify is great for the individual but not the collective. Maybe weâll all learn to listen in harmony and take a more âCâest la vieâ approach to music we donât like.
Actually, that gives me an ideaâŠB*Witched, anyone?